It sounds like you’re describing a vintage R.L. Winston 5/6 fly reel spool with an oil bottle that has some light scratches and wear. Here’s some helpful information based on your description:
1. R.L. Winston Vintage Reel Details:
– Winston reels from the mid-20th century are highly collectible, especially those made in San Francisco (pre-1973) or later in Twin Bridges, Montana.
– The 5/6 size indicates it fits a 5- or 6-weight fly line, making it ideal for trout fishing.
– Many vintage Winston reels were made by Hardy Bros. (England) or J.W. Young (UK) under contract, so they may resemble those brands.
2. Condition & Value Factors:
– “Slightly Scratched”: Minor wear is common on vintage reels and doesn’t always hurt value significantly, especially if mechanically sound.
– “Oil Bottle”: Original accessories (like oil bottles) add collectibility.
– “St” might mean “stamped” (e.g., with a serial number) or “stored”—clarifying this could help assess originality.
3. Estimated Value:
– Excellent Condition: $300–$600+ (rarer models or pre-1970s).
– Good Condition (with scratches): $150–$400, depending on rarity.
– With Original Box/Papers: Adds 20–30% to value.
4. Selling or Restoring?
– Selling: Highlight its Winston heritage, functionality, and any Hardy/Young markings. eBay, fiberglass fly rod forums, or vintage tackle dealers are good markets.
– Restoring: Light scratches can be polished out carefully, but avoid over-cleaning to preserve patina.
5. Authenticity Check:
– Look for “Winston” engraving, serial numbers, or “Made in England” (if Hardy-made).
– Compare to known Winston models (e.g., “Perfect” style or “St. George” clones).
Would you like help identifying the specific model or era based on photos/details? Or are you looking for a buyer’s guide? Let me know how I can assist further!